Whether you’re a novice or have played golf for years, you must’ve heard the old adage – “drive for show putt for dough”. Granted, both your long and short game equally matter, but there’s a grain of truth to the saying, seeing as over a third of all shots you’ll take are putts. And even if teeing off were more important than what you do on the green, getting to the dance floor is certainly the most nerve-wracking part of any hole. So, with all this in mind, let’s continue this best putters in golf review to see which they are.
A Few Things To Consider
Well, the first thing you’ll have to decide on when shopping for a new putter is the type. For those of you not in the know, we’ll paint with a broad brush and make a distinction between blades and mallets (though some add midsize mallet putters as a distinct category).
Sure enough, there are countless different putts in golf, as varied as players that take them, but it all comes down to a couple of sweeping categories – the arc and square-to-square. Pretty self-explanatory, right?
In a nutshell, some golfers move (or at least try to) the putter head in an arc, and those who prefer to move it in a straight line. If you’re an arc player, you might find the blade more suited to your game, and conversely, if you prefer going straight back and through, take a mallet.
Do Your Research
If you’re still not sure which is which, take a look at any standard issue putter at your local golf club – chances are it’s a blade. Its design is much more classic and simpler than that of its counterpart, which is why it’s preferred by more traditionally-minded players, as well as PGA Tour pros (on account of its feedback).
Mallet putters, on the other hand, are much more elaborate in design, and with more weight in the head. This has at least three advantages over the blades – better balance, larger sweet spot (the two sort of go hand in hand), and help with alignment. Also, seeing as they have more weight in the head, they’re great if you have a habit of using the putter off the green.
In short, the debate of blades vs. mallets really boils down to the debate between feel and forgiveness. Still, the best way to see what suits your game the best is to take a few putters and actually try them on for size, as it were, seeing as length is probably the most crucial component of a putter.
Here’s a nickel’s worth of free advice – take a standard shaft putter and assume the proper address position; if you’re gripping it down the shaft, get a shorter putter, and conversely, go for a longer one if you’re gripping it beyond the end.
Best Putters in Golf Comparison Table
Ping Sigma G Putters
Ping Vault Putters
Best Putters in Golf Review
Of course, you’re not limited to just the one putter in your bag. In fact, the number of recreational players advocating for two putters seems to be increasing (although we’re yet to see the trend among PGA pros). In any case, you can own as many of them as you like, and with our top ten best rated putter reviews, we’ll have you knocking down pins in no time.
1. Ping Sigma G Putters
The Ping Sigma G is one of the several new kids on the block, so it remains to be tried and tested in the long run. So far, though, it’s all good news.
The putter features a multi-piece face that was inspired by the soles of athletic shoes, of all things, and uses the same elastomer found in some of the high-end shoes.
Several brand-spanking new designs (the counter-balanced Doon, Kinloch, Ketsch B, to name but a few) are available, divided up into seven blades, five mid-mallets, and four mallets. That’s 16 different options, enough for all types of swings. Each model is available in either crispy Platinum or subdued Black Nickel.
To round off the range, Ping offers two grip options – a nice oversized roundish grip and a pistol tapered one.
The Odyssey White Hot RX comes with a decent selection of models, two blades, two mid-mallets, and three mallets (#1, #2, #7,#9, Rossie, V-Line Fang, and 2-Ball V-Line).
After over ten million White Hot clubs sold, Odyssey put in a new insert and gave us the White Hot RX, and a strong candidate for the title of the top golf putters.
The legend goes they tried 17 different inserts until ending up with an elastomer (instead of the urethane insert they’d used in older models). What this insert does is give you good resilience and an incredibly soft feel. This, in turn, gives enhanced ball speed (due to more spring) and a better roll.
Elastomers are all the rage these days in the world of flatsticks, and Odyssey is not the one to miss the game.
Their newest iteration of the O-Works line comes with an elastomer insert that is co-moulded with the equally innovative Microhinge surface (it’s exactly what it sounds like). What this does is provide better flex at impact and, consequently, more topspin and better roll.
The O-Works also features a slightly improved Versa Alignment Technology, which goes a long way to helping you with, well, alignment. As for the models in the range, they pretty much kept the selection from earlier gens (4 blades and 5 mallets).
The Cleveland Huntington Beach is a Tour-proven line of putters, and with a very approachable price tag, at that. If you’re looking for good golf putters that won’t break the bank, this just might be the range.
What sets the Huntington Beach Collection apart from other putters is that it features a milling pattern that is four times deeper than what you might be used to, which goes a long way to softening up the feel.
The selection in the way of head shapes is rather limited (three blades, one of which is women-specific, plus a mid-mallet), but they all look great.
Bettinardi makes some of the most extremely underrated putters out there, and their Studio Stock Series certainly fits the bill.
There are fifteen models to choose from, which should cover pretty much all types of swings, though you’ll need to break into the piggy-bank for those.
The Studio Stock Series was launched together with the Queen B Series, with the former aiming more at forgiveness and looks that inspire confidence, while the latter seems to be aimed at more proficient players and/or those who favour a more arcing stroke.
Both series are available with either of the two Lamkin grips (standard or jumbo deep-etched), which rounds off the offer rather nicely.
Along with the Select, the Titleist Scotty Cameron Futura forms the latest from Titleist and Scotty Cameron himself.
Now, while the Select is heavily blade-oriented, the Futura comes with 7 mallet designs, each looking better than the last.
Of course, it’s not all in the looks, and there’s so much under the hood that it’ll take a whole page to elucidate all the different technologies that go into making these puppies.
In a nutshell, you’re looking at a multi-material construction with perimeter weighting, which goes a long way to making putters more forgiving than your local pastor and more stable than the foundations of the church he’s preaching in.
The TaylorMade TP Collection is TaylorMade’s answer to players’ asking for a more classic-looking putter. Indeed, of all the highest rated putters out there on the market, the unfortunately-named TP Collection has the classiest.
The main selling points of the TP putters are the downward-facing 45-degree grooves, which give the face quite some teeth. On top of that, TaylorMade added the PureRoll, which is a new insert inspired by the one in their Spider Limited Red, the idea being to soften up the feel.
So far, six models are available – Juno (blade), Soto (blade), Mullen (mallet), Berwick (mallet), Ardmore (mallet), and Chaska (mallet), each available in three shaft lengths (33, 34, and 35 inches).
The TaylorMade Spider Tour comes in two distinct flavours, Red and Black, custom-made for two PGA pros – Jason Day and Dustin Johnson, respectively.
There’s also a third flavour, Platinum, which everyone seems to forget about, somehow. So, yeah, it stands to reason to say these are some of the best putters for golf on the market.
What the Spider brings to the table is specific to each of the three models, mostly due to the different materials each respective insert is made of. Also, the Platinum is the only version with a sightline, as it’s aimed at the average player.
Evnroll has fairly recently added three new models to their ER series (ER3, ER7, and ER8, one blade and two mallets, respectively). This makes for a grand total of eight different heads to suit pretty much any swing type.
Don’t fret if you haven’t heard about the brand, as it’s quite a new name. On that note, you might recognize the name behind the design – Guerin Rife, the godfather of putters.
Overall, the entire range is designed to give more forgiveness and better distance control thanks to the precise milling across the face and variable-width grooves.
On that note, if you need help with alignment, all ER putters feature a pair of very subtle dots on top, which go a long way to helping you with breaking putts.
10. Ping Vault Putters
The Ping Vault Series comes with a grand total of four models, two blades (Anser 2 and Voss) and as many mallets (Oslo and Bergen), and is one of the highest rated putter ranges on the market.
The blades are made of steel, while the mallets are all aluminum through and through, none of them featuring inserts.
What you’ll find in the Vault are four flatsticks with premium milled faces and variable-depth grooves (deep in the middle, shallower towards the ends), which adds an entire new level of forgiveness on off-centre hits. Granted, the offer is a bit limited, but it looks like Ping has left some room for additions.
The Final Word
So, to recap – given how over a third of all the shots you’ll take are putts, finding the perfect one is definitely something you’d want to take lightly. Bottom line, if you’d like to get the best putter for golf, you’ll need to find something you like to look at, and then try it out. As Scotty Cameron says, “looks inspire confidence”, and if the big man says something, you can take that to the bank.
The way things are right now, the majority of the flatsticks on our reviews list are fairly new, so long-term performance is yet to be qualified. On the flipside, all of them are available to us mortals to buy, even the Day’s and Johnson’s limited editions. Fairways and greens!